A Clue Between Rivals

A Clue Between Rivals

The case that was supposed to break them—and didn't.

by Vanessa Figueroa

24 chaptersen-US

Benjamin Foster and Laura Henderson have spent three years making each other miserable at Sterling & Cross. They snipe in meetings, take credit for each other's wins, and avoid the same hallways whenever possible. It is exhausting, and it is the best part of either of their days. Then senior partner Patrick Ward drops a case file on the desk and tells them to share the smallest office in the building until they solve it. Someone has been siphoning money from client accounts in amounts small enough to go unnoticed, and the trail leads somewhere inside the firm. They cannot agree on lunch, let alone a suspect. Every clue sparks a fresh argument. But when they discover that the old presentation that launched their feud three years ago was sabotaged by someone with high-level access, the investigation stops being a chore and starts being personal. Late nights and close quarters crack open secrets neither of them expected. A retired partner's user ID is still active. A pattern of after-hours logins points to a ten-million-dollar transfer hiding in plain sight. And when anonymous threats escalate to a break-in and a stalker who knows where Benjamin lives, they are forced into hiding together. The hatred was supposed to be the whole story. It turns out it was never hatred at all.

  • Romance
  • Mystery
  • Enemies to Lovers
  • Office Romance
  • Whodunit

The Window

Benjamin Foster arrived at seven in the morning because seven in the morning was when the office was supposed to be empty. He had coffee, he had a plan, and he had a deep, almost spiritual need to review the quarterly discrepancy reports before anyone else touched them. The hallway outside the converted storage room on the fourth floor smelled like old carpet and the faint chemical ghost of whatever cleaning solution the night crew used. He balanced his coffee on top of his battered leather messenger bag and pushed the door open.

Laura Henderson was already inside.

She sat at the desk against the left wall with her laptop open and a yellow legal pad already half-filled with notes in her tight, precise handwriting. Her dark hair was immaculate. Her white blouse had not a single wrinkle. She did not look up when he entered, but her pen stopped moving.

"You're early," Benjamin said.

"So are you." She still did not look up. "I assumed you'd want the desk near the door. Easier escape route."

"I want the desk near the window."

Now she looked up. Her expression was the same one she wore in every meeting where he presented an analysis she had not vetted first: polite, skeptical, and faintly insulted by his existence. "There's one window, Ben. It looks at a brick wall."

"It's still a window."

Through the grimy glass, the morning light arrived gray and defeated, as if it had already given up on the day before it began.

"Patrick wants us in his office at seven-thirty," Laura said. She twisted the silver ring on her index finger, a gesture Benjamin had cataloged years ago without meaning to. She did it when she was frustrated. She had done it during the Benton pitch. She had done it every time he spoke for the next three years.

"I know what Patrick wants."

"Do you know what the case is?"

"No. Do you?"

"No." She returned to her legal pad. "I was hoping you'd have figured it out and I could tell you why you were wrong."

Benjamin almost smiled. He caught it before it reached his mouth and killed it. "Give me an hour. I'll find something for you to be wrong about."

She uncapped her pen and drew a slow, deliberate line across the page, then another, as if he had not spoken at all.

Patrick stood behind his desk, silver-haired and impeccable, both hands resting on the back of his chair as if he were about to offer a toast. The office around him was all warm wood and soft leather, a room designed to make clients feel wealthy and reassured. "Benjamin. Laura. Sit down, both of you." He smiled at them like a proud uncle welcoming his favorite niece and nephew to Thanksgiving dinner, then gestured at the two chairs facing his desk. "Coffee?"

"We're fine," Laura said.

"I'm not," Benjamin said, but he sat anyway.

Patrick settled into his chair with the ease of a man who had not been rushed in thirty years. "I'll get straight to it. Our quarterly internal audit flagged a series of small discrepancies across three client accounts. Nothing that would raise alarms on its own, but the pattern is troubling. A few hundred dollars here, a few thousand there, all shuffled through different line items. The board wants answers, and they want them quietly. No memos, no department-wide emails, no rumors."

"How small?" Benjamin asked.

"Small enough that someone counted on nobody noticing. The total exposure so far is under two hundred thousand, but the pattern suggests it's been going on for a while, and the amounts are increasing." Patrick folded his hands on the desk. "I've picked my two best analysts to handle it. You'll share the case, and you'll share the office I've set up for you."

"The storage room," Laura said.

"The converted workspace," Patrick said.

"It's a storage room with desks in it," Benjamin said. "I saw the boxes."

Patrick's smile did not waver. "The proximity will facilitate collaboration. You'll have full access to the audit files, the client histories, and whatever else you need. Hannah will handle your support requests. I want weekly updates, and I want this resolved before the board meeting in six weeks."

"Pairing us is a mistake," Benjamin said.

"I couldn't agree more," Laura said, which was the only thing they had agreed on all morning.

"Noted." Patrick leaned back. "And overruled. You're both professionals. Act like it."

They walked back to the storage room in a thicker silence than before. Laura took the desk near the window without asking, sliding into the chair and pulling her laptop toward her with the possessive efficiency of someone claiming territory. Benjamin considered arguing and decided to save his ammunition for something that mattered.

"I'll take the first client file," she said. "You take the second. We'll split the third."

"I should take the first. I spotted the Henderson discrepancy two years before anyone else did."

"That was a payroll error. This is a different animal."

"Numbers are numbers."

"Numbers are numbers," she repeated, her voice flattening. "That's exactly the kind of thinking that gets analysts fired."

"I've worked here eight years. I haven't been fired yet."

"There's still time."

He rolled his sleeves to the elbow before he opened the first spreadsheet, a habit so ingrained he did not notice he was doing it. Laura noticed. Her gaze flicked to his forearms and then back to her screen, her expression unreadable.

By ten o'clock they had divided the files in a manner that satisfied neither of them. By eleven they had argued about methodology twice and about the formatting of a summary memo once. By noon they had made no progress on the discrepancies, but Benjamin had discovered that Laura's pen made a small, precise click every time she capped and uncapped it—a sound that arrived at irregular intervals and lodged somewhere behind his left eye—and Laura had learned that Benjamin's reading murmur was not a murmur at all but a low, arrhythmic mumble that bled through her noise-canceling headphones as if they were not there. The overhead light hummed at a frequency that lived inside both of their skulls now, and every time one of them shifted in a chair, the other felt it through the floor.

The door opened. Hannah Cooper appeared with a cardboard tray in both hands, her blonde curls escaping from a clip shaped like a ladybug.

"Okay, so," Hannah said, setting the tray on the corner of Benjamin's desk, "I brought coffee pods because someone—no names—raided the break room supply, and granola bars, and also ibuprofen because I could hear the shouting from the elevator." She smiled at them with the determined brightness of a woman who had decided this room would be cheerful whether it liked it or not. "How's the case going?"

"Great," Benjamin said.

"Fantastic," Laura said.

Hannah looked from one to the other. "You're both lying. That's fine. I'll be at my desk if you need anything that isn't a murder weapon." She set a small plastic bag of ibuprofen next to the coffee pods and retreated, shutting the door behind her.

Benjamin opened a granola bar. Laura twisted her ring. The light hummed.

"We should compare notes," she said, not looking at him.

"We should." He did not look at her either. "After lunch."

"Fine."

"Fine."

Neither of them moved. Outside the grimy window, the brick wall offered no opinion on any of it.

Two Desks

The second day was worse. Benjamin knew it would be worse before he opened the door, and he was right, which gave him no satisfaction at all. Laura had arrived at six forty-five and commandeered the entire whiteboard. She had drawn a timeline in three colors, each client account getting its own arc, with little annotated flags marking every discrep…

Read Next Chapter Free

Drop your email — chapters unlock immediately, no spam.