NO ONE SUSPECTED

NO ONE SUSPECTED

by Paige Manning

25 chaptersen-US

Twenty-six years ago, seventeen-year-old Emily O'Malley vanished from Belhaven, Texas, leaving behind shattered lives and whispers of a cover-up. Now, respected clinical therapist Daniel Hayes returns home, offering psychological insight to Emily's sister, Detective Lauren O'Malley, as a string of influential town leaders are systematically murdered. A retired principal bludgeoned in a municipal library. A wealthy developer poisoned in his private study. A physician strangled, a deputy drowned. Lauren suspects an organized serial killer targeting members of a buried past, unaware that Daniel is the executioner exacting righteous vengeance for Emily's vanished future. As Lauren and her partner dig into sealed town council records and long-buried family secrets, she uncovers a devastating revelation: Emily may not have died that night at all. Daniel has been methodically slaughtering powerful men for a murder that never took place. When Daniel realizes his life's crusade rests on a lie, he kidnaps Lauren's daughter to force an explosive final reckoning. But even as the righteous facade shatters, an unsettling photograph emerges, proving the truth is far deeper and deadlier than either imagined.

  • Thriller
  • Mystery
  • Crime Fiction
  • Psychological Thriller
  • Small Town Mystery
  • Serial Killer

The Homecoming

The folder on my desk is older than my daughter. The manila has gone soft at the corners, the kind of soft that comes from being handled, then shelved, then handled again by someone who wasn’t sure what they were looking for. I know every page inside it. I have known them for twenty-six years. Knowing them has never once made them easier to read.

EMILY O’MALLEY, the tab says, in handwriting that isn’t mine. DOB redacted by time and a leaking roof in the old records room. Last seen: Belhaven Municipal Park, August 14. I run my thumb along the edge of the paper the way other people might touch a worry stone, and I don’t open it, not this morning. I already know what isn’t in it.

“You’re doing the thing again.”

Mike sets a cup down in front of me before I can answer, the lid already loose the way I like it. Chicory coffee, bitter enough to strip paint, from the gas station two blocks over because the break room pot hasn’t produced anything drinkable since the Clinton administration.

“What thing.”

“The thing where you stare at that folder like it owes you money.” He drops into the chair across from me, and it groans under him the way it groans under everybody, a permanent complaint built into the furniture. “You’ve had that file open more times this year than we’ve had actual cases.”

“It’s a cold case. I’m allowed to look at cold cases.”

“You’re allowed. Doesn’t mean it’s good for you.” He peels back the lid on his own cup, blows across it, doesn’t drink. “I got something that’ll take your mind off it, for better or worse.”

“Worse, based on your face.”

“Guy opened a practice on Maple. Family counseling, the sign says. Nice office, used to be the old dry cleaner’s, the one that burned the lapel off my good jacket back in ’09.” He pauses the way he does when he wants me looking right at him for what comes next. “Daniel Hayes.”

The name lands the way certain names do, not loud, just heavy, settling into the room like something dropped from a height you didn’t expect. I set my coffee down so I don’t have to think about my hand around it.

“Daniel Hayes is back.”

“Moved in last week, from what I hear. Licensed therapist now. Framed degrees, the whole deal. Ramona at the diner says he’s already got a waiting list.”

I haven’t said his name out loud in years, not even to Hannah, not even to my father, who would rather chew glass than hear it at his table. Daniel Hayes, who used to sit with Emily on the bleachers behind the gym and talk about nothing for hours, who disappeared from Belhaven within a month of her and never once sent so much as a postcard back. Daniel Hayes, seventeen and quiet and always a half step behind Emily wherever she went, like a shadow that had learned to keep its own schedule.

“Twenty-six years,” I say, mostly to myself.

“Twenty-six years, and he picks now to come home and hang a shingle.” Mike watches me over the rim of his cup. “You going to be all right with that?”

“I’m going to be fine with that. People come back to their hometowns, Mike. It’s not a crime.”

“Didn’t say it was. Said you going to be all right.”

“I’m a grown woman and a homicide detective. I can handle seeing an old family friend on Main Street.”

“You call him a friend now.” He says it lightly, but his eyes don’t move off me, and I know what he’s doing, turning over a rock to see what crawls out from underneath. “Last time his name came up you called him something else.”

“That was a long time ago.” I close the folder, finally, and slide it to the side of my desk where it belongs, where it has belonged for years without ever quite managing to leave. “What’s on the board for today that isn’t him.”

Mike lets it go, because he always lets things go right up until the moment he doesn’t, and we spend the rest of the morning on paperwork that doesn’t deserve description. By noon my stomach has started complaining loud enough that I tell him I’m walking down to get something, and he waves me off without looking up from his screen, already halfway into whatever report has displeased him today.

Main Street in Belhaven hasn’t changed its bones in twenty years, even if the skin keeps getting replaced. The hardware store is a coffee shop now, has been for a decade, but the bakery on the corner is the bakery it has always been, run by the same family that’s run it since my mother was alive to buy bread there. The sidewalk is dry under a sky that can’t decide if it wants to rain, and I walk with my hands in my jacket pockets, half-thinking about the file I just put away, half-thinking about nothing at all, which is its own kind of luxury some days.

I don’t see him until I’m almost on top of him.

He’s standing outside the bakery door, a paper bag in one hand, wearing a wool coat the color of wet sand, the kind of coat that costs more than my whole wardrobe and doesn’t announce it, just sits there looking expensive and quiet at the same time. His hair has grayed at the temples in a way that looks deliberate, like he planned it. He sees me before I fully register who I’m looking at, and something in his face opens, warm and unguarded, the way a door opens when someone’s been waiting on the other side of it.

“Lauren.” He says my name like it costs him something to say it gently. “I wondered if I’d run into you.”

“Daniel.” My voice comes out steadier than I feel, which I take as a professional win. “Heard you were back.”

“Small towns.” He smiles, and it reaches all the way up, no performance to it that I can see, though I’ve learned not to trust a smile just because it looks honest. “Word moves faster than the mail here. Always has.”

“You look well.”

“You look tired.” He says it without judgment, the way a doctor might note a symptom. “I mean that kindly. You always did carry things in your shoulders.”

I don’t know what to do with that, so I don’t do anything with it. “Been a long week.”

“It’s always a long week in this job, I’d imagine.” He shifts the bag to his other hand, and for a second neither of us says anything, the quiet stretching just long enough to feel like something instead of nothing. “I think about this town more than I expected to, being away. I think about her.”

He doesn’t say Emily’s name. He doesn’t have to. It sits between us the way it always has, the way it probably always will, a third person in every conversation we’ve ever had and ever will have.

“Twenty-six years,” I say, echoing what I told Mike this morning without meaning to.

“Twenty-six years, and this town still hasn’t figured out how to carry it.” His voice is low, careful, the voice of a man who has spent a long time learning how to say hard things softly. “I used to think time would make it lighter. It doesn’t. It just changes the shape of the weight.”

I study him while he talks, the way I study everyone, an old habit that never clocks out even over bread and small talk. He looks calm in a way that unsettles me a little, calm the way still water is calm, nothing moving on the surface that tells you what’s underneath. There’s a steadiness to him that I don’t have, that I haven’t had in longer than I can remember, and for one unguarded second I feel something close to envy.

“You practicing here in town now,” I say. “Family counseling.”

“Among other things. Belhaven could use someone who listens for a living. God knows there’s enough that’s gone unsaid around here.” His eyes hold mine, warm and direct, no apology in them. “If you ever want to talk, Lauren. About any of it. My door’s open.”

“I appreciate that.” I mean it, and I’m surprised that I mean it. “I should get back. Mike’s probably eaten my lunch out of spite by now.”

He laughs, soft and genuine, and it’s a good laugh, one that makes the whole street feel briefly less gray. “Go. Don’t let him.”

I walk away with the strange, unfamiliar feeling of having been comforted by someone I barely know anymore, and it stays with me the rest of the afternoon, trailing behind me like a scent I can’t place, through two more hours of paperwork and a phone call from a reporter I don’t return.

By the time I get to my father’s house that evening, the feeling has mostly worn off, replaced by the low simmer that always starts up whenever I pull into his driveway. Hannah’s already there, sitting on the porch steps with her sketchbook open on her knees, her hair falling loose around her face in the way that still catches me off guard sometimes, the resemblance too close to something I try not to look at straight on.

“You’re late,” she says, not looking up from whatever she’s drawing.

“I’m a detective, Hannah. Late is the job.”

“Grandpa’s already in a mood. Fair warning.”

“When is he not.”

Dinner is pot roast, the same pot roast my father has made every other Thursday since before I can remember, and the kitchen smells the way it has always smelled, like onions and old wood and the particular dust of a house that’s been lived in by one stubborn man for too many years alone. Warren sits at the head of the table the way he’s sat at the head of every table he’s ever owned, back straight despite the hip that makes him wince getting into the chair, his Stetson hung by the door where it’s hung my whole life.

“Hannah tells me you’ve got some new gallery thing,” he says, cutting into his meat with more focus than it requires.

“It’s a group show, Grandpa. Three of my pieces.” Hannah’s voice goes bright in the particular way it does when she’s trying to drag him somewhere he doesn’t want to be led. “You should come. It’s at the community center.”

“We’ll see.”

“You always say that.”

“Because it’s always true.” He doesn’t look up. “Sometimes I come, sometimes my hip’s got other plans.”

It’s small talk, the kind our family specializes in, a wide moat built around any water deep enough to drown in. I eat and let them go back and forth, and for a few minutes it’s almost pleasant, almost the kind of dinner other families probably have without thinking twice about it.

Then, because I’ve never once in my life known how to leave well enough alone, I say it.

“Ran into Daniel Hayes today. Outside the bakery.”

The fork stops halfway to my father’s mouth. It’s a small thing, barely a hitch, but I’ve spent my whole career learning to read the small things, and I see it the way I’d see a flinch on a suspect across an interview table.

“Daniel Hayes.” He says the name like it’s something spoiled he’s just discovered in his mouth. “What the hell is he doing back here.”

“Opened a counseling practice on Maple.” I try to keep my voice light, the way I’d deliver any other piece of town gossip, but I can already feel the temperature in the kitchen dropping. “Mike mentioned it this morning.”

“He’s got no business back in this town.” My father sets his fork down with more force than the plate deserves, the clatter sharp enough that Hannah goes still across the table. “None. You hear me.”

“Dad, it’s a free country. The man grew up here same as I did.”

“He left. Good riddance when he did.” His jaw works, the muscle in his cheek jumping the way it only does when something old is clawing its way up from wherever he usually keeps it buried. “There’s no reason on God’s earth for him to come crawling back now, after everything.”

“After everything meaning what, exactly?” I lean forward, and I can hear my own voice sliding from daughter into detective, a shift I don’t bother fighting anymore at this table. “You’ve never once told me why you hate him so much. He was Emily’s friend. That’s it. That’s all he was.”

“That’s all he was.” He laughs, short and ugly, nothing like a laugh at all. “You don’t know the first thing about what he was.”

“Then tell me.”

“There’s nothing to tell.” His hands are shaking, just slightly, and he presses them flat against the table like he’s trying to hold something down that wants up. “Some doors don’t need opening twice, Lauren. I lived through it once already.”

“A man comes back to town and opens a practice, and you look like you’ve seen a ghost.” I don’t let it go, because I never know how to, because some part of me has been circling this exact moment for twenty-six years, waiting for the crack to finally show. “That’s not a normal reaction to an old family friend moving home, Dad. That’s a reaction to something.”

“Don’t you take that tone with me in my own house.”

“I’m not taking a tone, I’m asking a question you refuse to answer. You always refuse to answer. Every single time her name comes up, or his, you shut the door so hard I’m surprised the hinges still work.”

“Lauren.” Hannah’s voice, quiet, a hand half-raised like she’s trying to physically hold the room apart.

“Some things are better left where they are,” Warren says, and his voice has dropped, gone low and rough in a way that scares me more than the shouting would have. “You go digging where you’ve got no business digging, you’re not going to find peace. You’re going to find a mess, and it’s going to be a mess that costs you more than it costs anybody who’s already dead.”

“Somebody’s already dead, Dad. That’s my sister you’re talking about.”

He doesn’t answer that. He pushes his chair back instead, the legs scraping hard against the linoleum, and he walks out of the kitchen without another word, his bad hip forcing an uneven rhythm into his steps, the kind of walk that looks like a man trying to leave faster than his body will let him.

I sit there with my hands flat on the table, my own version of what he was just doing, and across from me Hannah has gone very still, her sketchbook closed now, her pencil set down beside it like she’s decided the evening doesn’t deserve to be recorded.

“You two do this every time,” she says, quiet.

“I know.”

“You ask him about her, and he shuts down, and you push, and he leaves, and it’s the same thing every single time, Mom. Doesn’t it ever occur to you that maybe he’s never going to tell you?”

“It occurs to me every time.” I push my plate away, appetite gone the way it always goes after these dinners, the pot roast suddenly just meat and salt and nothing worth finishing. “Doesn’t stop me from asking.”

“Why not?”

I don’t have a good answer for that, not one I’m willing to say out loud in my father’s kitchen with his hat still hanging by the door and his chair still pushed back at an angle that makes the whole room look wounded. I think of Daniel outside the bakery, his voice soft and sure, telling me the weight never gets lighter, only changes shape. I think of my father’s hands shaking against the table.

“Because somebody in this family has to keep asking,” I say finally. “Or we’re all just going to keep pretending she was never real.”

Hannah doesn’t answer that. She picks her sketchbook back up, flips it open to a blank page, and starts drawing something I can’t see from where I sit, her pencil moving slow and deliberate, the only sound left in a house that has gone, once again, entirely quiet around the one name nobody in it will say.

The Stacks

The call came in before the sky had decided what color it wanted to be. Mike was already at the curb when I got there, his cruiser idling, his breath fogging in short bursts against the cold windshield. “Library,” he said, before I’d even shut the door. “Custodian found him in the archive room. Says it’s Richard Bell.” “The old principal?” I buckle…

Read Next Chapter Free

Drop your email — chapters unlock immediately, no spam.